Why We Cook: Matzo Ball Soup

Cook, Why We Cook

This post comes to us courtesy of writer and mixologist Warren Bobrow.


My grandmother was in very poor health when I was growing up. She spent her winters in Miami Beach at my family’s former home on Hibiscus Island. It was a grand home on the bay, and I will always remember going down to the palm tree-surrounded house for Christmas a few times when I was a boy. There would be both a Christmas tree and a Menorah; we were not a blended family in any way other than the appreciation of all national holidays, especially ones that involved large family meals. Making foods like Matzo Ball soup is a culturally relevant example for why I cook and the foods that I still enjoy today.


Every time I make a pot of Matzo Ball soup, immediately I’m transported to my grandmother’s kitchen at Shangri La. Estelle, our family cook, would have cut up a few freshly killed fat birds on the broad stainless steel tables. They lay there, resplendent in their elegance and in my mind’s eye. The vegetables would be cut up and there was always much commotion in the kitchen between my great-grandmother and others who would always have to give their unsolicited advice.


Whenever I add a few onions, carrots and celery stalks to a pot of spring water containing the perfect Pullet chicken, I’m connected to the first time I saw my great-grandmother make this soup for my ailing grandmother. She knew that Jewish penicillin might not cure all ills, but it couldn’t hurt!


Matzo Ball soup is one of those historic recipes that connects each subsequent bowl of soup with all of those preceding it. Every taste of this soup is perfect and contains more than just ingredients — it contains memories of my grandmother, Sarah and her mother, Yetta. My stock is made with care from the same ingredients that she used, including parsnips, onions, carrots and celery. My great-grandmother taught me that the parsnip adds depth and balance against the Matzo meal. Her Matzo Balls contained a healthy pinch of nutmeg; she said this was essential and I still make mine this way. She also warned in a stern but caring fashion never to lift the lid off the pot, even for a second, to check the balls: “They’ll be as hard as golf balls, heavy as stones!”


Now, decades later, each bowl of this soup is like a flavor-driven time machine, transporting me to the past — a veritable healing journey into my family history, one steaming and savory sip at a time.


Yetta’s Chicken Soup for Matzo Balls


1 or two pullet chickens (find some nice fatty ones)

5 carrots, roughly chopped

6 stalks celery, roughly chopped

6 onions, ends cut off (do not peel)

6 parsnips, sliced into coins

1 large bunch of dill

2 to 4 quarts spring water


In a non-reactive stainless steel pot, add all of the ingredients. Use spring water instead of tap. Bring to a nice simmer and cook until the chicken falls off the bone. Be careful not to burn the soup, stirring every so often.


Remove carcass and onions from the soup and correct seasoning. When cool enough to handle, strip chicken meat from carcass and add back into pot. Make sure no bones stay in the soup, but use as much of the chicken as possible to make your soup. Cool overnight in the fridge.


The next morning, scoop the congealed fat off the top and reserve for your Matzo Balls.


Matzo Balls from Yetta (with love)


2 cups Matzo meal

A good pinch of salt

1 tsp. freshly grated nutmeg

2 eggs, at room temperature

4 to 5 Tbs. reserved chicken fat from your soup

1/4 tsp. freshly ground black pepper

3 Tbs. seltzer water


Mix all the ingredients together and let rest for at least an hour covered with a damp cloth in the fridge.


Form the Matzo Balls with your hands. Try not to make them too perfect! Add to a pot of boiling chicken stock or water, reduce heat to a simmer and cover for at least 30 minutes. Take off the heat and rest (with the top still in place) for at least 15 minutes more.


Open carefully and add the Matzo Balls to your chicken soup. Then, with spoon in hand add with reverence into pre-heated bowls. Enjoy! Serves 4 to 6.


About the authorWarren Bobrow is the Food and Drink Editor of the 501c3 non profit Wild Table on Wild River Review located in Princeton, New Jersey. Warren was an Iron Mixology Judge at the Charleston Wine and Food Festival 2012. He attended Tales of the Cocktail in New Orleans in 2011. Warren has published over three hundred articles in fewer than three years since his reinvention from executive assistant in private banking to author. Warren writes with a unique free-form style. He is a writer/mixologist on everything from cocktail flavoring and Biodynamic/organic wines to restaurant reviews. He writes for Edible Jersey, Voda Magazine, Foodista, Tasting Panel, Beverage News and Total Food Service Magazine. Warren is the “On Whiskey” columnist for OKRA Magazine in New Orleans part of the Southern Food and Beverage Museum. He was born and raised in Morristown, NJ on a Biodynamic farm.

9 comments about “Why We Cook: Matzo Ball Soup

  1. Laurie @LG_Interiors

    My grandparents lived in the Bronx. We would visit every Sunday and my grandmother’s meal always included chicken soup. To this day, when I walk into an old NYC apartment building, I have to think, “is that the chicken soup I smell or lead paint.” There is such a nostalgic aroma. Our family version is a strained clear soup; no vegetables or chicken. But whenever I make it, we always huddle around the pot to eat the chicken when it first comes out. That’s when it’s best.

  2. All with love and then we dance….. « Greatpoetrymhf’s Weblog

  3. Eric Riback

    I’ve been using a recipe from the NYTimes with success for several years, but with this buildup, how can I not try it?!

  4. Warren Bobrow

    Thank you Eric. I like a heavy hit of nutmeg. Connects me with the Caribbean. I have a feeling that the tribe came through there somehow. Anyway. Cheers. wb

  5. Why We Cook: Matzo Ball Soup | Author of Apothecary Cocktails, Bitters and Shrub Syrup Cocktails, Whiskey Cocktails & Cannabis Cocktails

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *